|
|
|
14433 4 5 1 |
|
Опции темы | Поиск в этой теме |
21.07.2010, 21:09 | 1 |
Модератор своих разделов
Регистрация: 03.07.2010 Последняя активность: 10.10.2022 08:53 Адрес: Copenhagen, Denmark
Сообщений: 1652
Сказал(а) спасибо: 0
Поблагодарили: 2983 раз(а) в 1024 сообщениях
|
A look at AAA flashlights
A look at AAA flashlights.
This review is the first part of my AAA review, the second parts is here: Beamshoots from AAA flashlights. Other AAA comparisions: January 2010, Mr.Lite KC-05, June 2010, July 2010 This review is about AAA battery powered lights, each light will include a short description, some photos, indoor white wall and outdoor beamshot. I collect flashlights and like them with different colored bodies, but that does not mean that the lights only exists in the color I have, most lights exist in more discrete colors. The flashlights I will include are (same sequence as in picture): Arc AAA, Ti ARC AAA, Killer AAA, Tiablo A1, Streamlight Microstream, LumaPower Avenger GX, Tank 007 TK-701, Leatherman S1, Leatherman S2, Fenix E01, Fenix L0D, Fenix LD01, Maglite Solitaire, Led Lenser P2, Led Lenser P3, LiteFLux LF2X, LiteFlux LF2XT, Peak Matterhorn #1, Peak Matterhorn #2, Peak Eiger, Peak Baltic. It is Peak Eiger, Streamlight Microstream and Ti ARC AAA in my hand. Flashlights can be categorized in many different ways, I will start by listing some categories, explain them, and list the lights that are in that category. Emitter type Today most flashlights use LEDs (Light Emitting Diodes) and there is a reason for that. Some of the advantages of LEDs are:
LEDs are not without any disadvantages, the main one is their color rendering. The light from LEDs does not contain the full spectrum, but are missing some colors, this will affect how some colors look. What colors are affected depends on the color of the LED, e.g. if it is ”cool white” or ”warm white”. For use outdoors in natural settings, the ”warm white" has an advantage, see beamshots for the Peak Eiger for an example of a “warm white” beamshots.
Operation The lights in this review can be split in two different main operating types, twist and push button. The button has some sub catagories.
Settings Modern flashlights often have more settings, e.g. a high setting with lots of light and short runtime, and a low setting with much lower light output and long runtime. The lights might also have some flashing settings (e.g. SOS and strobe). Some of the most advanced lights have the ability to adjust the settings (programmable), including both light levels and flash settings. All these possibilities can be an advantage or a liability, depending on how and for what the flashlight is used.
Brightness Depending on type of light emitter and how it is controlled, light can be made with a wide range of light output, from weak lights that can be used to locate a keyhole but not spoil the night vision, to bright light that can fill a big room with light and definitely spoil any night vision. This review is about AAA lights and that battery size imposes a limit on maximum output, but anybody that has only used old style incandescent flashlights is in for a big surprise.
Note: Peak light only has one brightness setting, but that setting can be specified when ordering the light. Battery type The heading to this review says AAA batteries and some people will probably believe that this defines the battery type, but that is not fully correct. There are multiple AAA sized battery types, most can be used interchangeably, but one AAA sized battery is very different.
Material and surface treatment
How to carry the flashlight These small lights are designed to always be carried, some of the typical ways to carry them are:
Using these lights, you usual hold the light in a hand, to prevent dropping it, you can secure it with a lanyard around the wrist. Here is shown a cheap lanyard, that uses a thin wire to attach to the light, a better lanyard will use a ring instead. If you need both hands, you can hold the light with your mouth, or if it has a clip mounted at the head, the light can be mounted on a hat brim and be used as a headlamp. Flashlights ARC AAA This light has been on the market for a long time, but with occasional updates. The light is not one of the cheapest on the market, but has proven that ARC known how to make a very reliable light, that can take all the bumps from everyday use. The light does not have any spring behind the battery, i.e. be careful not to tighten the light too much. NOTE my version is the UV light, the beam shoots only shows the visible part of the spectrum, a ARC with GS led will be a bit more powerful than the Fenix E01 Current consumption: 150mA Mass with battery: 24 gram Volume: 8.7 cm3 Light emitter: 5mm led, it is possible to select different types. User interface: Twist Settings: 1 level Can be bought here: http://www.arcflashlight.com/ ARC AAA Ti This light is from ARC and McGizmo (McGizmo calls it ”Titanium Sapphire AAA”), the light was made as an experiment and was sold out rather fast, both manufacturers have decided to make a new series of them. Opposite most other lights with a 5mm LED, this light does have a front glass, not an exposed LED. From ARC this light can be bought with two different LEDs and it is possible to buy both and change between them. The light does not have any spring behind the battery, i.e. be careful not to tighten the light too much. Here is a picture of the replaceable led module, this one is the 3mm DS version: Current consumption: 140mA Mass with battery: 28 gram Volume: 9 cm3 Light emitter: 5mm led (Nichia white GS) or 3mm led (Nichia white DS) User interface: Twist Settings: 1 level Can maybe be bought here: http://www.arcflashlight.com/ Killer AAA This flashlight is manufactured in Titanium and is a custom light (i.e. it is only made in a limited number), it has a very high finish. My version is a special run that was colored with “Splash” colors. This light uses a special 5 mm led with multiple dies, that is supposed to give more light, but I have not been able to confirm it with my measurements. Looking at the led in the picture, it can be seen that it has a lot of wires inside, it is because it is the special high power version. Current consumption: 230mA Mass with battery: 34 gram Volume: 9.8 cm3 Light emitter: 5mm led User interface: Twist Settings: 1 level Can be bough here: http://photonfanatic.com/Li... Tiablo A1 Tiablo's AAA light. A nicely designed one level flashlight. The removeable clip is mounted in a recess and will not slide during use and a GITD (Glow in the dark) ring is mounted on the light, making it easy to locate the light during blackouts. Current consumption: 700mA Mass with battery: 30.5 gram Volume: 12.6 cm3 Light emitter: Luxeon Rebel 100 User interface: Twist Settings: 1 level Streamlight Microstream A aluminum light with a nicely focused led. The light includes a clip, that can not slide, but can be removed. Due to the design the clip will scratch the flashlight body, when replacing the battery and the surface treatment is only type 2. The light is supplied with a lanyard and a split ring, but the light has no hole for mounting the ring (I supposed it must be mounted on the clip). Turning the tailcap will lockout the light, and the switch is also a bit hard to press. Streamlight are very confident about the strength of the light and promises that the front glas and the clips are unbreakable. Current consumption: 200mA Mass with battery: 30.5 gram Volume: 14 cm3 Light emitter: power led User interface: Button, forward switch Settings: 1 level LumaPower Avenger GX Lumapower has selected to make a light with 3 fixed levels and then be flexible in the physical design. They supplies two tailcaps, one with a switch and one without, the switch can either be with GITD (Glow in the Dark) or black. The light is supplied with two clips a metallic and a black, but they are not a very strong constrution. The clip can be mounted in either end of the light and the knurling prevent it from sliding off the light. Also included with the light is a lanyard and a lobster claw, they can either be mounted to the clip or to the tailcap without switch. I believe that it is a nice collection of accessories, but would have prefered some more solid clips and a way to mount the laynard/lobster claw directly on the tailcap with switch. Selection of light level is done with fast on/off sequences, the selected brightness will be remembered to next turnon. For a light without switch, the twist is between head and body, this can also be used as lockout when the switch is mounted. The light uses pwm at 1.3 kHz to control the brightness, these two traces shows low and medium brightness, there is no pwm on high: Low: Medium: High: Low, medium, high Current consumption: low:65mA, medium:265mA, high:640mA Mass with battery: min. 34 gram without button and accessories, 43 gram with button, clip and lobster claw. Volume: 15 cm3 Light emitter: Cree XP-E power led User interface: Twist or Button, forward switch Settings: 3 levels Tank007 TK-701 This is a rather cheap flashlight, but for the low price it is ok. The only problem I have seen on the lights is the missing spring for the battery. The battery will press directly against the top and bottom of the battery tube. Tightening the light too much can damage the light, on my light it will disable the light, but loosing it up again will fix it. The light output is not very high, and it has a rather high current consumption. Current consumption: 570mA Mass with battery: 31 gram Volume: 12.8 cm3 Light emitter: Power led from SSC User interface: Button, reverse switch Settings: 1 level Can be bought here: http://www.dealextreme.com/... Leatherman S1 Leatherman's small flashlight with one output level and a switch to turn on/off. The light has both a ring and a clip, making it very flexible how to carry it. The ring holder must be mounted when using the clip or the clip will slide off. The button makes it easy to use the light with one hand and will make this light an obvious candidate for people that need to turn the light on/off often. The light output from it is purple, like other GS lights and the light output is the same as the Fenix E01. Current consumption: 70mA Mass with battery: 33 gram Volume: 12.6 cm3 Light emitter: 5mm led (Nichia white GS) User interface: Button, reverse switch Settings: 1 level Leatherman S2 Leatherman's big AAA flashlight with two output levels, one very low and one very high. The light has both a ring and a clip, making it very flexible how to wear. The ring holder must be mounted when using the clip or the clip will slide off. The button makes it easy to use the light with one hand and will make this light a obvious candidate for people that need to turn the light on/off often. The light always comes on in low and a light press on the button will change to high. The front of the light is in stainless steel, this will protect the light from falls on hard surfaces. The light uses pwm at 100 Hz to control the brightness, these two traces shows low and high brightness: On low: On high: Low, high Current consumption: low 114mA, high 760mA Mass with battery: 36 gram Volume: 13.5 cm3 Light emitter: Power led from Cree User interface: Button, reverse switch Settings: 2 levels Fenix E01 An inexpensive light from Fenix, with long battery lifetime, it uses a 5mm LED. This LED is weak compared to other Fenix lights and the light color is a bit purple. The construction is solid and good quality. This is one of the few lights that exist in multiple colors: Current consumption: 85mA Mass with battery: 26 gram Volume: 11 cm3 Light emitter: 5mm led (Nichia white GS) User interface: Twist Settings: 1 level Fenix L0D Fenix old (2007/200 version of a powerful AAA light. The light is turned on by tightening it together. Twisting it loose and tight again will change to the next setting. It will always come on at medium, next is low, then high, strobe, sos. My version is the xmas 2007 version, the normal version has a more discrete black color. Even with the ring for keychain mounting, the light can stand on its tail. The light uses pwm at 100 Hz to control the brightness, these two traces shows low and medium brightness, there is no pwm on high: Strobe is 8.3 Hz and is at full brightness, i.e. no pwm. The sos sequence is 13 seconds long and with 10 seconds between. On low: On medium: On high: Low, medium, high: The flashlight can take a lot of abuse, the two lights in the picture have both been in the washing machine and the black has also been in the tumble dryer, where I found it in 3 pieces (Head, body and battery). The most obvious sign of the mistreatment is the scratches at the front. Both lights are still working. Current consumption: low 107mA, medium 270mA and high 780mA Weight with battery: 27 gram Volume: 11.5 cm3 Light emitter: Power led from Cree User interface: Twist Settings: 3 light levels, strobe and sos Fenix LD01 This light is an update of L0D, the biggest change is the removal of the flashing modes. The light is turned on by tightening it together. Twisting it loose and tight again will change to the next setting. It will always come on at medium, next is low, then high. My version is the stainless steel version, the normal version is black aluminum. The light uses pwm at 1.25 kHz to control the brightness, these two traces shows low and medium brightness, there is no pwm on high: On low: On medium: On high: Low, medium, high: Current consumption: low 150mA, medium 300mA and high 770mA Mass with battery: 47 gram for SS model. Volume: 11.6 cm3 Light emitter: Power led from Cree User interface: Twist Settings: 3 light levels Maglite Solitaire An old well known flashlight and the absolute weakest in this roundup of small lights. The light also has a short runtime at full output and then a steady declining output. The light has a very warm light color from the incandescent bulb. Maglite does make this light in multiple colors, but they uses a weak surface treatment (Type 2), i.e. the surface will get scratches very fast, if the light is used on a keychain. With the bezel removed the light can be used for area lightning, e.g. in a tent. With bezel mounted and focused: With bezel mounted and not focused: Without bezel: The above pictures are a bit dark, to show the beam I have takes a serie more with increased exposure, for the one without bezel I did increase exposure twice. I.e. the pictures are: With bezel mounted and focused, With bezel mounted and not focused, Without bezel, Without bezel With bezel mounted and focused: Current consumption: 212mA Mass with battery: 24 gram Volume: 10.3 cm3 Light emitter: Incandescent bulb User interface: Twist Settings: 1 level Led Lenser P2 This is a inexpensive light, but good for the money. I got the light in a packing where it was possible to try the light, without unwrapping it, an extra battery was also included. The light also included a lanyard and a holster. The optic on this light is a bit special as it includes a real lens with a focus adjust. To adjust the focus, the head must be turned. The light is not perfect, the surface treatment is only type II and not very scratch resident, the clips can slide of the light and it does not have any lockout function. The instruction warns against using NIMH and Lithium batteries. Focus adjustment: Wide focus: Narrow focus: Wide and narrow focus: Current consumption: 320 mA with fresh battery, will drop when battery is used Mass with battery: 39 gram (with included AAA battery) Volume: 15.9 cm3 Light emitter: 5 mm Nichia led User interface: Button, forward switch Settings: 1 level Led Lenser P3 This light is nearly the same as P2, except that the head on the light is bigger and does not turn, instead it slides to change focus. The supplied accesories are also the same, but only one battery, because this box has no test button. Focus adjustment: Wide focus: Narrow focus: Wide and narrow focus: Current consumption: 320 mA with fresh battery, but drops fast when light is on. Mass with battery: 42.3 gram (including supplied AAA battery) Volume: 21 cm3 Light emitter: 5 mm Nichia led User interface: Button, forward switch Settings: 1 level LiteFlux LF2X The world's most advanced AAA flashlight and also a very powerful flashlight. The light comes in a wood box with some accessories: lubricant, diffuser and two tail caps, either as necklace or with a clip. This light is turned off when tightened, loosen it to turn it on, there are two loose positions (marked P1 and P2 on the body) to select between two settings. All other settings are done by fast changing between these two positions, this requires good dexterity or a bit of light to see the markings. The light has a memory that can remember the last selection and all the programming. The programming is very extensive, all light levels and timing of the strobe modes can be programmed. All types of batteries can be used Alkaline/Lithium/NiMH and Li-Ion. Alkaline cells are not recommend because they cannot deliver enough power for the light to reach full power. When using Li-Ion the max. output will be nearly double of the other battery types, this is by design and it not outside the specifications, but do not run the light to long on full power (it gets hot). The necklace has a special quick release connection to the light, but I do not like the lock, it is not safe enough for me. The light does not include any good possibilities for putting it on a keychain, but it is possible to make one that can replace the clip. This is not a light for people that believe a VCR is hard to program. I will recommend to download the manual, before buying the light. LiteFlux has developed a new version of this light, called LF2XT (Adding T to the name), see below for a description. The light uses pwm at 7.8 kHz to control the brightness, the trace here shows min. level: On min. with NiMH: On max. with NiMH: On min. with LiIon: On max. with LiIon: On max. with LiIon and diffuser: Low, high and high with diffuser, running on NiMH Low, high and high with diffuser, running on LiIon Current consumption with NiMH battery: off 5uA, min. 10mA, max. 1100mA Current consumption with LiIon battery (Type 10440 with 320mAh): Off 20uA, min. 4mA, max. 780mA (This is about double the power compared to NiMH) Mass with battery: 34 gram (31 with LiIon) Volume: 12.4 cm3 (With clip) Light emitter: Power led from Cree User interface: Twist, with 3 positions: off-P1-P2 Settings: 3 light levels, 2 strobes, 2 sos, all can be programmed. Can be bought here: LED Cool or Eliteled LiteFlux LF2XT A new version (2009) of the worlds most advanced flashlight, this time the twist is replaced by a tail button, the light is still very powerfull. In the new version the accessories has been reduced, the light is still supplied in the wood box , and includes lubricant, extra o-rings, clip and a keyring, but no diffuser or ball chain. The light has two different user interfaces, when delievered it is in the simple mode, i.e. press the button to turn on or off, hold the button to change light output. Pressing a code, the light changes to the advanced user interface with 5 settings, where each setting can be program to a brightness or a flashing mode (The flashing modes are not the same as LF2X). The light can use any type of AAA battery, but alkaline are to weak for full power. The light is designed to use LiIon and the increased brightness with LiIon is within specifications for this light. The light uses pwm at 1.9 kHz to control the brightness, the trace here shows min. level: On min. with NiMH: On max. with NiMH: On min. with LiIon: On max. with LiIon: Low, high, running on NiMH Low, high, running on LiIon Current consumption with NiMH: off 2uA, min 18mA, max 1000mA Current consumption with LiIon: off 7.5uA, min 5.2mA, max 620mA Mass with battery: 34 gram (31 with LiIon) Volume: 13 cm3 Light emitter: Cree XP-E power led User interface: Button, electronic signal Settings: variable brightness or 5 position all can be programmed for brightness or flashing modes Can be bought here: LED Cool, kuku427 or Eliteled Peak Led Solution Matterhorn #1 This is a brass AAA light from the Matterhorn serie, this serie contains many different lights, because it is possible to order material, battery size, brightness and some other details. This light is with one led and brightness "UP". The diffuser for this light is a bit special, it has a hole in it. My light is in brass and the construction feels very solid and as can be seen on the picture, it is also possible to get a smaller battery tube for the light, I have tried that in my Look on small flashlights. Without diffuser: With diffuser: Without and with diffuser: Current consumption: NiMH:60mA, LiIon:85mA Mass with battery: 46.5 gram Volume: 9.5 cm3 Light emitter: 5mm led User interface: Twist, but it can be ordered with a momentary pushbutton. Settings: 1 level Can be bought here: http://www.peakledsolutions... Peak Led Solution Matterhorn #2 This is a stainless steel light from the Matterhorn series (See above). This light has 3 led's and brightness "UP". For this battery tube I also got a momentary push button, hold it down for light or screw the light together for constant on. Like the brass version, this light feels very solid. Without diffuser: With diffuser: Without and with diffuser: Current consumption: 230mA Mass with battery: 48 gram Volume: 10.8 cm3 Light emitter: 3 x 5 mm led User interface: Twist, but it can be ordered with a momentary pushbutton. Settings: 1 level Can be bought here: http://www.peakledsolutions... Peak Led Solution Eiger This is a new (2009) AAA flashlight from Peak, it has the same size as Matterhorn series and match parts with it, but instead of a 5 mm led it uses a power led. On top of all the usual body options, this light also has 8 power levels and 3 different optic that it can be ordered with. I have bought 2 brightness levels #2 and #8, both with medium optic, I did also order some extra bodies and can use 10180, 10280, AAA and 2xAAA batteries. With #2 and NiMH: With #2 and LiIon: With #8 and NiMH: With #8 and LiIon: #2 with NiHM og #8 with NiMH Current consumption with NiHH: #2=105mA #8=860mA, #8 is ustable in current measurement. Current consumption with LiIon: #2=80mA #8=1000mA Mass with battery: 49 gram (47 med LiIon) Volume: 13.5 cm3 Light emitter: Rebel 100 power led User interface: Twist, but it can be ordered with a momentary pushbutton. Settings: 1 level Can be bought here: http://www.peakledsolutions... Peak Led Solution Baltic This is a stainless steel light from the Baltic series, this serie contains many different lights, because it is possible to order material, battery size, brightness and some other details. This light has one led and brightness "SUP". The battery tube can be equipped with a momentary pushbutton, to turn on permanently the ligth must be screwed together. This light also has the diffuser with the hole in. Like the other steel lights, this light feels very solid. Without diffuser: With diffuser: Without and with diffuser: Current consumption: 530mA Mass with battery: 55.5 gram Volume: 13.5 cm3 Light emitter: power led User interface: Twist, but it can be ordered with a momentary pushbutton. Settings: 1 level Can be bought here: http://www.peakledsolutions... Mako This is a custom light made in a small serie. The light is made in titanium with a really good finish. The light has two levels, when twisted together it first goes on at low level with a bit more twisting it changes to high level (That is not really that high). The light has a slot for a trit and I have mounted a "ice-blue" in mine. The light was manufactured with two different beam spreads, a focuesed and a non focused, mine is the non focused version. Current consumption: low: 18mA, high 60mA Mass with battery: 28 gram Light emitter: 5mm Cree led, in 15º or 60º version. User interface: Twist Settings: 2 levels Manufacturer: http://muyshondt.net/ Maglite 2C flashlight Led lights with power led has a high output, here I have taken some pictures of the 2C Maglite: The Maglite can concentrate the light more, due to the big reflector, but the total light output is not higher than for some of the small AAA lights (But it has longer runtime). Notes All pictures of the light output are made with fixed exposure and locked daylight white balance. The camera settings are:
This exposure makes the brightness step between the pictures 4 times. All current measurements and weight/mass measurements are with Eneloop NiMH batteries, this battery is rated for 800mAh uA is used for micro ampere and 1000uA is equal to 1mA The volume is calculated as a cylinder and does not include clips/rings/lanyards, I also do some rounding for bottom shape.
__________________
My website with reviews of charges, batteries and other stuff: http://www.lygte-info.dk/ |
21.07.2010, 21:21 | 2 |
Администратор
Регистрация: 17.05.2010 Адрес: Москва
Сообщений: 18407
Сказал(а) спасибо: 4327
Поблагодарили: 10641 раз(а) в 2539 сообщениях
|
Re: A look at AAA flashlights
Потрясающий обзор коллекции!!!
|
22.07.2010, 00:34 | 3 |
Увлеченный
Регистрация: 15.07.2010 Последняя активность: 24.10.2017 22:12 Адрес: Областная Москва
Сообщений: 71
Сказал(а) спасибо: 0
Поблагодарили: 3 раз(а) в 3 сообщениях
|
Re: A look at AAA flashlights
Да, обзор потрясающий, наверное. Я наверно не на том сайте зарегился, блиин и обзор свой первый не на том языке написал. Надо было на CPF выложить, там бы все, сто процентов, поняли меня.
|
22.07.2010, 00:41 | 4 |
Администратор
Регистрация: 17.05.2010 Адрес: Москва
Сообщений: 18407
Сказал(а) спасибо: 4327
Поблагодарили: 10641 раз(а) в 2539 сообщениях
|
Re: A look at AAA flashlights
Намек понят. Но я физически не могу переводить все обзоры с английского, которые выкладываются на нашем форуме.
|
09.07.2011, 17:35 | 5 |
Olight fan
Регистрация: 12.03.2011 Последняя активность: 04.07.2022 22:01 Адрес: Киев, Украина
Сообщений: 3915
Сказал(а) спасибо: 5056
Поблагодарили: 1241 раз(а) в 682 сообщениях
|
Re: A look at AAA flashlights
Отличный обзор и коллекция!
Приглядываюсь к парочке наключников из этого ряда. |